Carbon steel takes a very sharp edge and is easy to sharpen, but it rusts if left wet and darkens with use (a patina). Stainless steel has chromium (about 12% or more) that resists rust, so it needs less care. Neither is “better”: it is a trade between maintenance and edge feel.
Aogami No.1 (Blue Paper No.1)
Carbon steel from Proterial (formerly Hitachi Metals, Yasugi works), not stainless; chromium and tungsten are added.
- Hardness
- “60 HRC or more” in standard processing (the maker’s figure).
- Rust risk
- High; dry it right after use.
- Care
- Wash by hand, dry at once and apply a thin coat of food-safe oil for storage.
- Note
- More carbon than No.2; described as sharper and a bit more demanding to look after.
Aogami No.2 (Blue Paper No.2)
Same family as No.1 with less carbon; chromium and tungsten are added.
- Hardness
- “60 HRC or more” in standard processing (the maker’s figure).
- Rust risk
- Susceptible; same care as No.1.
- Note
- Described as the more balanced and popular of the two.
Shirogami No.2 (White Paper No.2)
Plain carbon steel, about 1.05–1.15% carbon, no chromium.
- Hardness
- “60 HRC or more” in standard processing (the maker’s figure).
- Rust risk
- It rusts if not looked after straight away; wash it, dry it thoroughly and oil it.
- Note
- Easier to sharpen than No.1, with a little less edge retention.
Carbon steel (SK)
“SK” is the Japanese standard (JIS G 4401) for carbon tool steel; SK5, for example, has about 0.80–0.90% carbon.
- Rust risk
- Like any carbon steel (see the introduction).
Carbon steel
Carbon steel of a grade the maker does not name. Rust and care as in the introduction.
DSR-1K6 stainless
Martensitic stainless steel from Daido Steel (Japan) made for cutlery: about 0.60% carbon, 13.5% chromium and a little molybdenum.
- Rust risk
- Resists rust well, but it is not rustproof; dry it after use.
- Care
- Easy; wash it by hand.
- Note
- Often compared with AUS-6.
Stainless steel
Stainless steel the maker does not name; it resists rust, is easy to look after and the edge is usually less fine than that of carbon steel.
Not sure which to choose?
Message us and we will help you pick based on what you cook.